Former Ethiopian Foreign Minister Challenges PM Abiy’s War Narrative in Explosive Open Letter

ADDIS ABABA – 5 FEBRUARY 2026 – In a remarkable and unprecedented public rebuke, Gedu Andargachew, a former high-ranking Ethiopian official, has published a detailed open letter directly contradicting Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed’s account of Eritrea’s role in the Tigray war and alleging the PM displayed open contempt for the Tigrayan people.

The letter, addressed to “His Excellency Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed,” is a point-by-point rebuttal of statements Abiy made in Parliament on February 3, 2026, where the Prime Minister cited Gedu as a witness regarding Ethiopia-Eritrea relations.

Direct Challenge on Eritrea’s Role

Gedu’s most significant claim fundamentally alters the official narrative of the 2020-2022 war. He asserts that the Eritrean army was a consistent, integrated ally of the Ethiopian National Defense Force (ENDF) from the very beginning.

“From the outset of the war in Tigray until it was halted by the Pretoria Agreement, there was hardly a moment when the Eritrean army was not fighting alongside the Ethiopian National Defense Forces,” Gedu writes. He provides a specific military detail, alleging that when Tigrayan forces advanced into the Amhara region in mid-2021, “the Eritrean army operated as far as the vicinity of Debre Tabor.”

He states the two armies functioned as “a single force” and only ceased joint operations after the Pretoria ceasefire was announced, directly challenging narratives that sought to minimize or obscure the extent of Eritrean involvement.

Allegations of Moral Failure and Deflection

The letter accuses PM Abiy of avoiding responsibility for the war’s catastrophic human toll. “After such widespread destruction, I expected that you would seek forgiveness from both the people of Tigray and the people of Ethiopia,” Gedu states. Instead, he claims the Prime Minister engages in “distorted” storytelling to “deflect responsibility.”

Gedu links the Tigray conflict to ongoing crises in Amhara, Oromia, Benishangul, and Gambella, arguing they are “primarily the result of your weak governance and the mistaken belief that political survival requires perpetual conflict.”

Explosive Claim of Abiy’s Contempt for Tigrayans

The letter’s most incendiary passage recounts a private meeting Gedu says occurred after the capture of Mekelle in late 2020. After Gedu advised establishing civilian rule to avoid fueling resentment, he claims Abiy summoned him and expressed a radically different view.

Gedu quotes the Prime Minister as allegedly saying:
“Gedu, do not think the Tigrayans can recover from this defeat and rise again. We have crushed them so they will not rise… Who are the people of Tigray above? We have broken them so they will not rise again. We will break them even further. The Tigray we once knew will never return.”

Gedu presents this as evidence of Abiy’s “true attitude toward the people of Tigray.”

Denying a Secret Humanitarian Mission

Gedu forcefully denies Abiy’s parliamentary claim that he was sent to Eritrea as a special envoy concerning atrocities in Tigray. He clarifies he resigned as Foreign Minister “within days of the outbreak of the war.”

He confirms a single trip to Asmara in early January 2021 but describes a mission with three military-focused objectives: congratulating President Isaias Afwerki on joint operations, thanking Eritrea for hosting the shattered Northern Command, and coordinating a response to mounting international “human rights violations” allegations.

Critically, Gedu claims that when he suggested asking Eritrea to withdraw its forces—as the international community demanded—Abiy explicitly forbade it. “You explicitly instructed me not to raise this issue under any circumstances,” he writes. He states unequivocally that “no message whatsoever concerning the suffering of the people of Tigray was conveyed.”

A Call for Historical Truth

Presented as a necessary act of conscience, Gedu’s letter concludes, “This is the truth as I know it.” It stands as a direct challenge from within the former political establishment to the Prime Minister’s version of history, demanding a reckoning with the war’s conduct and moral consequences that, the author implies, has yet to occur.

The Prime Minister’s office has not issued an immediate public response to the allegations.

For more detail see the official Amharic letter of Gedu Andargachew

For more information see the English copy of the letter of Gedu Andargachew